BITCOIN, REAL ESTATE & THE ORDONIO SCAM
I have skin in the game (I have Bitcoin holdings, a good friend of mine is the top Bitcoin expert in Europe and I have plans to integrate Blockchain technology to one of our SaaS company), so I was itching to make this article. The recent ₱900,000,000 Bitcoin scam perpetrated by Arnel and Leonady Ordonio is both sickening and ludicrous.
Sickening on one end as this scam leads to a lot of financial, emotional and psychological harm to the victims and ludicrous on another end, since people, mostly adults with good education and government work, still fell for this get-rich-quick scheme.
It’s the Philippines’ very own version of BITCONNNEEEEEECTTTTT!! For those that doesn’t know, BitConnect is a Bitcoin Ponzi scheme in the US. You can read more about it here.
Here’s a graphic of the BitConnect’s Referral Program:
With BitConnect, investors were promised 1% return per day. For a $1,000 investment, an investor could earn as high as 40% profit per month!
What happened behind the BitConnect scene was the same pyramid scheme utilized by other Ponzi criminals: 1st investor’s money gets sent to 2nd investor as profit, 2nd investor’s money get sent to 3rd investor, so on and so forth. Once all of it got exposed, everything fell like a house of cards.
This was the very same tactic the Ordonio group employed:
“Under the scheme, investors were promised of at least 30 percent profit in about half a month for a minimum bankrolled capital of P90 thousand. Some of the investments went as a high as P29 million.” –CNN Philippines
Here’s a graphic the Ordonio group used:
Now that shit hit the fan, what could the victims do?
It’s highly unlikely that the Ordonio’s would return the money, but there’s still a slim chance to get some of it back. When they reached ₱500,000,000, they could’ve bailed and flew out of the country, but they didn’t. This indicate that, yes, they were greedy, but more importantly, they were not that smart.
I did a little digging to determine what happened to the Ordonio’s Bitcoin holdings and what I found out was pretty interesting.
Where do we begin?
Bitcoin transactions are permanently recorded through the Bitcoin Blockchain, making it traceable. This has been proven by the FBI with the capture of Ross Ulbricht, the creator of Silk Road, an online black market for drugs, guns and other illegal items and services.
We start with Arnel Ordonio’s Bitcoin wallet address.
On Mach 17, 2018 (10:46 PM), Arnel shared a Facebook post containing 2 screenshots from his mobile Gmail app.
The screenshot contains emails from Cloudbet, a Bitcoin betting and casino platform.
These Cloudbet emails contain Bitcoin wallet addresses, which we could presume, is owned by Arnel.
1ST BITCOIN WALLET ADDRESS: 18DkDKV29Zciqys8rZkT2kJTzRwQkaScMQ
Using Blockchain.info, we can trace all the transactions of this 1st address.
You can take a quick look at the transactions of this address here: https://blockchain.info/address/18DkDKV29Zciqys8rZkT2kJTzRwQkaScMQ
The 1st Bitcoin wallet address had 6 transactions and contained BTC 5.2 on February 23, 2018, which at that time had a value of $39,519.01 (or approximately ₱2,052,909.82 | 1$ = ₱51.9474).
In less than 11 hours, he cashed out $150.18 (₱7,801.46) using this wallet 39YgHuxY2s7Hi2u9sMJfodrFTp3WR8gW1S and moved the remaining balance of $30,041.66 (₱1,560,586.128) to this other wallet 1HP8jTTwWtPVwfrwEjKAwbvM9f4pm8whRT.
2ND BITCOIN WALLET ADDRESS: 1Nbwso5tC6JDRyG4gW9n8LPdvB7z1BtLSf
This 2nd Bitcoin wallet address had only 2 transactions and contained BTC 3.9, equivalent to $30,021.89 (or approximately ₱1,559,559.128 | 1$ = ₱51.9474).
The ₱1,559,559.128 was kept for 6 days inside this 2nd wallet.
3RD BITCOIN WALLET ADDRESS: 13WA1WX5QNL5LEDKboEvphzm22reCnaNmb
This 3rd address had 2 transactions and contained BTC 3.9 or $30,055.70 on Feb 24, 2018. At that time, $1 was equivalent to ₱51.8240, so the value of the wallet was ₱1,557,606.596.
They kept the money in this wallet for 9 days.
4TH BITCOIN WALLET ADDRESS: 13WA1WX5QNL5LEDKboEvphzm22reCnaNmb
This final wallet also had 2 transactions and contained BTC 3.9 or $30,108.55 (approximately ₱1,560,345.495 at a $1 = ₱51.8240 exchange rate.
Within 24 hours, the money was drained from this wallet.
In total, Arnel received ₱6,730,421.04 in the 4 wallets or 0.75% of the reported ₱900,000,000 that his group was able to obtain.
I had initially wanted to track down all the wallets to see where the money went, but after a few hours of checking, it was apparent that they were splitting the Bitcoins into several wallets, cashing out some and further distributing the remaining Bitcoins. It would be very time consuming to track all. It’s the most obvious tactic to confuse and slowdown the police authorities.
Retrieving Part Of The Scammed Money
The only positive thing I could get from my initial tracking activity is that the money from the 1st Bitcoin wallet address is still on the move as of April 12. This means, the cohorts of the Ordonios’ are still active and might be looking to cash out soon.
It would be to the best benefit of the Criminal Investigation and Detection Group (CIDG) to work with the management of Coins.ph, Rebit.ph, LocalBitcoins.com, BuyBitcoin.ph and other registered Bitcoin exchanges in the country, in tracking the Bitcoin wallet addresses and stopping the remaining fugitives from cashing out. If they allow the cash out of the Bitcoins implicated in this scam, they can be liable in aiding money laundering.
Another possible option to retrieve some of the money, is by getting a hold of the Bitcoin wallet of the Ordonio’s. This means the CIDG must confiscate all the electronic devices (computer, laptop, cellphones, hard drives, CD’s, flash drives, simcards, memory cards) of the Ordonio’s, including the devices of their relatives and all paper documents inside their properties (house, car, etc) to look for their 12 Word Backup Phrase. This 12 Word Backup Phrase can help open their Bitcoin Wallets.
It is highly likely that the Ordonios’ kept a stash of Bitcoin hidden safe from the authorities through a small piece of paper or a memory card, which they could withdraw if they get out of jail or through a dummy. ₱900,000,000 is a huge sum, so the CIDG must not leave any stone unturned.
The Sad Realty
Apparently, this wan’t taken too seriously. *Greed.
It should be made clear that the Ordonio group used Bitcoin as front for their Ponzi scheme. Bitcoin, as digital currency, is not a scam.
SO HOW IS THIS CONNECTED TO REAL ESTATE?
We’re a firm believer that Bitcoin and the technology that makes it work, called Blockchain, is the future of real estate. We’ve shared our thoughts on this topic: BITCOIN & BLOCKCHAIN TECH FOR PHILIPPINE REAL ESTATE & REAL ESTATE INNOVATORS USING BITCOIN & BLOCKCHAIN.
Negative press on Bitcoin impacts the future of our Bitcoin-Real-Estate-related projects.
One project that we have on the pipeline is the integration of blockchain in the record-keeping of listings. As you might have seen in the Bitcoin wallet address tracking activity, all the Ordonio’s Bitcoin transactions were recorded permanently, they cannot obfuscate or hide their transactions. Once recorded, it will also be impossible to change, modify or delete. In very simple terms, a record on the blockchain means it is stored in a decentralized system; if a person would like to change, modify or delete a record, s/he would need to change all the record from the other users, INDIVIDUALLY.
The implication of this decentralized technology in real estate is huge! One use case would be to utilize this to store the listing transactions for rental properties.
i.e. We can have a permanent historical record of Condo1 in terms of who the lessee and lessor was, when and who were the agents/brokers involved, how much was the rental fee and what were the terms of rent. People from 30 years in the future can backtrack the history of the property! Disputes could easily be resolved by simply checking on the blockchain record of the property since it cannot be tampered by anybody.
This is the power of Bitcoin and its Blockchain technology. This is the reason why I dedicated time in writing this piece, to help do my part in protecting Bitcoin’s reputation in the Philippines.
My wife is angry that I slept at 6:00AM last Friday (April 13), when I started writing this, and now at 1:39am, still finishing it.
There you have it. I’m done and off to sleep.
Good luck to the victims!